Police and Crime Panel (PCP)

The Commissioner’s work is assessed, supported and challenged by the Police and Crime Panel (PCP). This is to make sure that the public has the information they need to consider or challenge decisions. In this way, the PCC can be held to account.

Panel members focus their attention on important strategic actions and decisions made by the PCC, including whether they have:

  • achieved the aims in the Police and Crime Plan and Annual Report.
  • considered the priorities of community safety partners.
  • consulted appropriately with the public and victims of crime.

Membership is balanced according to the geographical and political make-up of the County, with similar consideration given to the Panel members’ skills, knowledge and experience. It is hosted, managed and administered by Derbyshire County Council for complete independence.

Members are required to:

  • consider the Commissioner’s proposed council tax precept for policing, with power to veto this if they consider the level is not appropriate.
  • consider the Commissioner’s proposed appointment of a Chief Constable, with the power to veto if they consider necessary.
  • review the Commissioner’s Police and Crime Plan and the Annual Report.
  • consider any non-criminal complaints against the PCC.

The Panel can also request reports and call the Commissioner to attend its meetings.

Who is on the Panel

Derbyshire’s Police and Crime Panel is made up of the following members:

  • Mrs Vicky Newbury – Independent Member (Chair)
  • Councillor Clive Moesby – Bolsover District Council – (Vice Chair)
  • Councillor John Wright – Derby City Council
  • Councillor Dawn Abbott – Derbyshire County Council
  • Councillor Elaine Sharman – Amber Valley Borough Council
  • Councillor Steve Lismore – Chesterfield Borough Council
  • Councillor Nick Wilton – Derbyshire Dales District Council
  • Councillor Mark Alfrey – Erewash Borough Council
  • Councillor Simon Evans – High Peak Borough Council
  • Councillor Jayne Barry – North East Derbyshire District Council
  • Councillor Stephen Taylor – South Derbyshire District Council
  • Dr Stephen Handsley – Independent member
Co-opted members
  • Councillor Jonathan Smale (CON) – Derby City Council
  • Councillor Carol Hart (CON) – Erewash Borough Council
  • Councillor Melandra Smith (REF) – Derbyshire County Council
  • Councillor Justin Gilbody (IND) – Bolsover District Council

Correspondence with the Panel

A copy of letters received from the Police and Crime Panel and associated responses are available below for information:

Correspondence from the Panel to the PCCCorrespondence from the PCC to the Panel
Letter from the Panel following the confirmation hearing of Dr Fatima Eltinay as Deputy PCC – July 2025The Commissioner’s response to the Panel following the confirmation hearing – July 2025
2025/26 Precept Letter to PCC from the Panel – January 2025The Commissioner’s response to the Panel on the 2025/26 Precept – January 2025
Letter from the Panel on the Police and Crime Plan 2024-29The Commissioner’s response to the Panel on the Police and Crime Plan 2024-29
Letter from the Panel following the confirmation hearing of Mr. Thomas Spray as Deputy PCC – November 2024The Commissioner’s response to the Panel following the confirmation hearing – November 2024
Letter from the Panel following the confirmation hearing for the Chief Constable for Derbyshire Constabulary – September 2024The Commissioner’s response to the Panel following the confirmation hearing – September 2025
Letter from the Panel on the Annual Report 2023 to 2024 – October 2024The Commissioner’s response to the Panel on the Annual Report 2023 to 2024 – October 2024

PLEASE NOTE: With the exception of legally required data and historic financial records, the majority of the information on the Derbyshire OPCC website covers information, news and events for the current Commissioner only. For access to news articles and information covering the previous Commissioners please contact the OPCC team.

Translate »
Skip to content